Tax Season Scams: Protecting Your Identity and Financial Assets
Tax season is often considered the “Super Bowl” for your books, but while you are focused on gathering records and meeting deadlines, criminals are ramping up their efforts to exploit the season. Identity thieves see this time of year as a prime opportunity to trick taxpayers into revealing sensitive personal data. Their ultimate goal? Filing fraudulent tax returns to steal your refund or compromising your financial accounts to create a lasting nightmare.
At Thomas Hawbaker CPA PLLC, we often talk about the importance of protecting yourself from identity theft because we have seen the fallout. Having your identity stolen is a complex, exhausting experience that can take years of professional intervention to resolve. Scammers are relentless and incredibly clever, frequently evolving their tactics to bypass common defenses. It only takes one moment of distraction or one clicked link for your financial security to be compromised.
Understanding the Scope of Tax Scams
Identity thieves frequently masquerade as the IRS or other federal agencies, such as the U.S. Department of the Treasury, to lend their schemes an air of legitimacy. They may use official-looking logos, forged signatures, or sophisticated website clones to convince you that their communication is genuine. This type of deception is designed to lower your guard so you will reveal credit card numbers, bank account credentials, or your Social Security number.
These scams are generally delivered through four main channels: letters, faxes, emails (phishing), and phone calls or text messages (smishing). Once a fraudster has your personal data, they don’t just stop at filing a false tax return. They may use your credit to apply for new loans, run up charges on existing cards, or even claim government benefits in your name.
Protecting Midlothian Seniors from Financial Predators
Experience shows that scammers frequently target those over the age of 65 or individuals approaching retirement. These criminals often use high-pressure tactics to solicit personal information or direct payments. For those in our Midlothian community, it is vital to know that the consequences of these scams extend beyond the immediate loss of funds. If an individual is tricked into distributing money from a tax-deferred retirement account, those lost funds may still be treated as a taxable distribution. This can result in ordinary income tax and, if the account holder is under 59½, potential early withdrawal penalties. While some victims may be eligible for a theft loss deduction, navigating that process is technically demanding and requires professional guidance.
We encourage families to maintain open lines of communication. If an elderly family member receives an unusual message regarding their taxes, suggest they discuss it with a trusted advisor before taking any action. These conversations are a powerful tool in safeguarding the generational wealth you have worked hard to build.
How to Spot the Red Flags of a Scam
Phishing emails and smishing texts almost always share common traits designed to bypass logical thinking. They create an artificial sense of urgency—telling you that you are in legal trouble, that your account is on hold, or that you have an unexpected prize waiting for you. Be extremely cautious of any unsolicited request for payment or personal data, especially those demanding immediate action. Here are the specific warning signs of a fraudulent email:
Requests for Excessive Information: The IRS will not ask for your mother’s maiden name or credit card numbers via email.
The Refund “Bait”: Messages that entice you with a refund you weren’t expecting or offer payment for participating in an IRS survey.
Threatening Language: Scammers often use fear, threatening arrest, deportation, or the blocking of your financial accounts.
Naming Errors: Frequently, scammers get the names of federal agencies slightly wrong or use odd phrasing that suggests the sender is not a native English speaker.
Suspicious Links: Hover your mouse over any link to see the actual URL. If it doesn’t start with www.irs.gov, do not click it. Look for slight misspellings or unusual extensions.
Common Phishing and Smishing Tactics
Criminals use these digital traps to install malware on your devices or harvest your login credentials through fake websites.
The Most Common Phishing Emails
- Phony Refund Notices: Emails claiming you have a large refund waiting and must click a link to claim it.
- False Legal Charges: Alarming messages threatening immediate arrest for “tax fraud.”
- Underreported Income: Scammers send “tax statements” as attachments that, when opened, infect your computer with malware.
- Account Updates: Requests to “update your IP PIN” or login through a link that mimics the IRS portal.
The Rise of Smishing (Text Scams)
- Account Activity Alerts: Texts claiming “Unusual Activity Reported” with a link to “restore” access.
- Economic Impact Payments: Messages about unexpected government payments designed to steal your bank info.
- Callback Scams: Texts that provide a phone number to call, connecting you directly to a fraudster who will try to extract your data.
Proactive Defense: The Identity Protection PIN
One of the most effective tools in your arsenal is the Identity Protection PIN (IP PIN). This is a unique six-digit number assigned by the IRS that verifies your identity when you file your federal return. If someone attempts to file using your Social Security number without this PIN, the IRS will automatically reject the return. A new IP PIN is generated every year for security. If you have previously been a victim of identity theft, you are likely already enrolled. However, any taxpayer who can verify their identity can voluntarily join the program through the IRS Get an IP PIN tool.
The Danger of Social Media Tax Myths
Misinformation is rampant on social media, often spread by “influencers” who lack formal tax training. They may encourage taxpayers to falsify information to maximize credits or claim that the IRS is “hiding” certain refunds. Following this advice can lead to audits, heavy penalties, and even criminal charges. Furthermore, these posts are often gateways for scammers looking to exploit your trust. For accurate tax planning and IRS tax problems, it is essential to rely on a qualified CPA rather than a viral video.
Conclusion: Your Safety is Our Priority
The IRS will never initiate contact with you via email, text message, or social media to request your personal or financial information. Their primary method of communication remains official notices sent through the U.S. Postal Service. With over 38 years of experience in small business and personal IRS taxation, Tom Hawbaker and our team are here to help you navigate these risks.
If you have received a suspicious message or need assistance resolving IRS tax problems, please contact our Midlothian office. We provide the personalized attention that software packages simply can’t match, ensuring your financial life remains secure and compliant.
The threats facing taxpayers today extend far beyond anonymous digital hackers or automated bots. One of the most insidious threats involves what the industry calls “ghost preparers.” These are unethical individuals who offer tax preparation services but refuse to sign the returns they prepare. In the tax industry, anyone who is paid to prepare or assist in preparing federal tax returns must have a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN). Ghost preparers often print the return and tell the taxpayer to sign and mail it themselves, or they refuse to digitally sign the e-file document. By not signing the return, these individuals avoid accountability, leaving the taxpayer to face the IRS alone when the return is flagged for suspicious credits or deductions. Many of these preparers promise “inflated” refunds based on fabricated business expenses or false household employee credits. As a firm committed to the standards of professional accounting, we cannot stress enough the importance of checking a preparer’s credentials through official government directories before sharing your financial history.
For the small business community in Midlothian, another high-stakes scam has emerged involving the Employee Retention Credit (ERC). You may have heard advertisements on the radio or seen pop-up ads claiming your business is entitled to thousands of dollars in government stimulus money, even if you did not experience a significant decline in revenue. These aggressive promoters, often referred to as “ERC mills,” charge high upfront fees or a percentage of the refund to file complex claims that the business may not actually qualify for. The IRS has significantly increased its scrutiny of these claims, and business owners who file improper ERC returns face not only the repayment of the credit but also steep penalties and interest. If an offer sounds too good to be true, it likely is. It is always safer to consult with a professional who understands your specific business operations and cash flow before submitting such claims to the federal government.
The psychological tactics used by these criminals are designed to bypass your logical defenses by triggering an emotional response. By creating a high-stress environment, they force victims into a “fight or flight” response. They might claim that an immediate wire transfer or the purchase of gift cards is the only way to avoid a lawsuit or immediate asset seizure. This is never how the IRS operates. The agency provides taxpayers with several levels of appeal and the right to challenge the government’s position through a formal process. This “Taxpayer Bill of Rights” is a cornerstone of our tax system. These rights include the right to be informed, the right to quality service, and the right to retain representation. Understanding these rights can help you stay calm and collected when a scammer attempts to use intimidation to steal your hard-earned money.
If you find yourself in the unfortunate position of having your identity compromised, the road to recovery requires a methodical and documented approach. The first step is usually filing IRS Form 14039, the Identity Theft Affidavit. This form notifies the IRS that a fraudulent return has been filed or that your personal information has been stolen. You should also place a “fraud alert” on your credit reports with the three major credit bureaus. This prevents scammers from opening new lines of credit in your name while you resolve the issue with the tax authorities. Be prepared for a lengthy process; the IRS units handling these cases often have a significant backlog, and it can take many months to fully rectify an account and receive your legitimate refund. During this time, staying in close contact with your CPA is essential to ensure all correspondence is handled correctly.
To stay ahead of these threats, we recommend a “security-first” mindset for all our clients throughout the year, not just during tax season. This includes using long, unique passwords for every financial account and enabling multi-factor authentication whenever possible. At Thomas Hawbaker CPA PLLC, we prioritize the security of your data by using encrypted communication channels and secure client portals. Avoiding the transmission of sensitive documents like W-2s or 1099s through standard email is one of the easiest ways to reduce your risk profile. We are dedicated to staying current with the latest tax laws and digital threats to provide the best possible support for our neighbors in Midlothian and across Texas. By staying vigilant and working with a trusted professional, you can focus on growing your business or enjoying your retirement without the constant shadow of financial fraud.
Want tax & accounting tips and insights?
Sign up for our newsletter.